Monday, October 14, 2019

A Blizzard of Trouble

Last week must have been the worst for Activision-Blizzard, particularly the Blizzard part.

Chances are you've already heard about this as international media has reported on it but here is the Blitzchung drama.

On Monday the 7th of October, Chung “Blitzchung” Ng Wai, won a Hearthstone grandmasters tournament and in the interview that followed he said: ”Liberate Hong Kong, revolution of our age”. The livestream was immediately shut down.
In very short order Blitzchung was stripped of all his winnings and slapped with a one year ban from Blizzard e-sports. The two shoutcasters (commentators) were also suspended by Blizzard for a year.

So, an American corporation punishes a Hong Kong citizen for showing solidarity with his people in their fight for human rights and democracy? Hang on now... A press statement in the west calmly stated that Blitzchung had violated the rules of the tournament by talking about something besides the game... and that's why they took everything away from him? Well read on.

In the East, Blizzards message was a bit different. There are a couple of different translations of the Mandarin Chinese message but the content is essentially the same: We are very angry and we will always uphold and defend the dignity of China. I'm paraphrasing but that's essentially what it said.

So now the American corporation is punishing a Hong Kong player on behalf of Communist China? Not good...

This blew up in an incredible storm of fury all over the world. A Norwegian member of Parliament wrote to Activision CEO Robert Kotick, asking him to do the right thing. U.S. politicians on both sides have condemned Activision-Blizzard. Human Rights watch groups are furious and fans are boycotting, canceling their subscriptions and even deleting their Blizzard accounts in protest. The amount of cancellations got so bad that Blizzard either tried to stop it by shutting down the pages where you delete your account or the system crashed under the load.

The fury continued to grow and all Activision-Blizzard said was: We're evaluating our situation. Then on Friday the 11th just before the closing of business, Blizzard president J. Allen Brack issued a statement.


Not only is this a weak non statement, but the language is so grammatically weird that some are suspecting that is was written in Chinese and not in English. I have no evidence either way. However, phrases like:

We now believe he should receive his prizing” is not really how an American normally writes.

So now Blitzchung gets his prize money and is “only” suspended for six months as are the casters.

To make the whole mess messier, a U.S. Hearthstone team in another league held up a sign during a tournament stating “Free Hong Kong, Boycott Blizzard”. The camera was pulled away from them but they received no punishment whatsoever, even though their message was harsher than Blitzchungs.
In protest, the American University team forfeited the match and dropped out of the tournament. This does illustrate that Blizzards actions had nothing to do with the rules and everything to do with appeasing China.

Some Blizzard employees have protested via a walkout and even covered up the parts of the statue outside Blizzard HQ that says “Every voice matters”.

Now with Blizzcon only a couple of weeks away, peaceful protests are being organized so it might be an interesting convention.

That's the story in a nutshell, if you want more, Youtube has dozens of videos on the subject. But, what's the bottom line here?

China is an enormous market for both mobile and PC games, and Activision-Blizzard is obviously very keen on not offending the Chinese government, because those who do, are not welcome to do business there. The CCP can, have and will throw out any and all companies that they deem unsuitable.
It is sad that Activision-Blizzard is so keen on nothing but money that this event has taken place but perhaps it's a good thing that we know the truth.


That's it for me, join me again next time and until then, have a great week!

No comments: