While browsing movies on
Letterboxd, I found:
Child 44 (2015).
A movie set in The Soviet
Union starring Tom Hardy and Gary Oldman sounded amazing so I sat
down and gave it a go.
The story with mild, mild
spoilers is this: Leo Demidov (Tom Hardy), hero of WWII is an officer
in the MGB, the pre-precursor of the KGB. He is married to the love
of his life Raisa (Noomi Rapace), and he is good at his job. A child
is found dead, clearly murdered, but Soviet doctrine states that
there are no murders in paradise, and that serial killers are a
product of capitalism, so the verdict is accidental death. Shortly
thereafter Leo falls from grace and is sent to a small industrial
town with Raisa. Another kid turns up dead, and he just can't ignore
it anymore, state or no state.
If that sounds familiar,
the story is inspired by the hunt for real life serial killer Chikatilo.
I was really hesitant to
even write about this movie. Child 44 is an interesting mix of
quality and problems. The actors are amazing. Tom Hardy, Gary Oldman,
Charles Dance (one scene only), Vincent Cassel and more is a great
cast. No complaints there, they knock it out of the park.
Visually, Child 44 is
amazing. The props department outdid themselves. Everything looks
amazing. Sure there are some errors, but unless you are an expert,
you really can't tell. Full points here.
The script? Now we're in
trouble. The movie is 137 minutes long and it wastes so much time.
The initial setup is good, the introduction of Leo and his colleagues
is good, but then it goes off the rails a lot. Child 44 is based on a
novel with the same name by Tom Rob Smith and I saw a reviewer claim
that they took a real page turner and made a clunky, slow and boring
movie. I don't agree with that statement, but I can see where that
person is coming from.
My biggest problem with
the story, is focus. It should be about catching a depraved serial
killer in a land where that can't happen, but that is almost a side
note when you look at what they spent time on. In the end the
inhumanity of the Soviet system is far worse than a person who kills
children, bizarre a statement as it is.
Child 44 goes back and
forth seemingly unsure of that to do. There are scenes that are
really good, and I love Raisa who goes from an unhappy wife to an
equal partner essential to the story. But on the other hand they
set up things that go nowhere, and other things aren't explained at
all.
So, do I recommend this
movie? Yes and no. I'm still very conflicted. The good parts are
really good, but that bad parts come so close to taking over. I do
not regret watching Child 44 but it should have been so much better
than what we got. I also can't help compare it to Citizen X (1995)
which is about the real life hunt for Chikatilo, and is a better movie. In the end you
should watch it if the subject matter interests you, otherwise give
it a miss.
That's that and all that.
Join me again next time and until then, have a great week!