Having seen a couple of clips on Youtube, I watched:
The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare (2024).
This movie claims to be based on true events from Winston Churchill's diaries, but that should be taken with a grain of salt.
Churchill is desperate to do something about the German U-boats, so he tasks Brigadier Gubbins (Cary Elwes), who together with Ian Fleming (Freddie Fox) recruits Major Gus March-Phillips (Henry Cavill). He is a rogue and constantly in trouble, but the ideal man for unconventional commando operations. March-Phillips puts together a team, and they go off to destroy an Italian tanker, the Duchessa d'Aosta, that is supplying the U-boat fleet with carbon-dioxide filters (they didn't use these in real life). The ship is in the Spanish controlled colony of Fernando Po in Africa. Lots of action ensues.
The event in question did happen, and is called Operation Postmaster. It is also true that several high ranking British officers were vehemently against commando warfare, seeing it as well, ungentlemanly. So far so good, but the movie has some problems. When I started watching, I had no idea that the director is non other than Guy Ritchie, who's movie The Gentlemen I recently reviewed with great pleasure. I thought The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare would be a serious war movie with some comedic elements, but it is in fact a pulp action movie with lots of comedic elements. The British commandos are total superhuman soldiers, hitting everything they shoot at even without really aiming. They are almost completely unfazed by the enormity of what they have to do. It gets a bit silly to be honest.
The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare is so full of errors that I don't even want to try to list them all. Some are small issues like how their silenced STEN guns weren't developed until a few years later, that doesn't bother me, but uniforms are wrong (Gestapo officers in army general staff uniforms, military behavior is wrong (Sitting indoors wearing hats), essentially lots of small things that screamed at me when watching.
So what is good about The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare? Well, everything else. It is really nicely made, the action is great, most of the dialogue is good, although there are a few stinkers in this department. The music suits the movie perfectly. Once I understood what the movie is, I could relax and start enjoying myself. Guy Ritchie is best known for his British crime movies, and a war movie is a very different beast.
I couldn't help but compare The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare with SAS: Rogue Heroes, which is also about the birth of unconventional warfare. SAS is a mini series and could thus take it's time and show background issues, and political problems. The Ministry of Ungentlemanly Warfare is a two hour movie and it wastes too much time going in this direction with no payoff. It had been better if it had focused solely on the commandos instead.
So, do I recommend this movie? Yes. You may get the impression that I didn't like it, but I complain because I liked it. Watch it as a pulp action comedy, and you will have a good time. Ignore all attempts at viewing it in a documentary light, and it works. I may even watch it again at some point.
That's that and all that. Join me again next time, and until then, have a great week!